Replies

  • Votre version suit plutôt les franciscains, celle que je propose suit les bénéventains!
     
    Geert Maessen a dit :

    Dear Dominique, just to let you know,

    Yesterday in Amsterdam I presented a book with a selection of the restitutions of my gregoguru, Wim van Gerven (1929-2008). Two criteria for the selection were: handwritten and actually performed by his scholae. The book contains 197 restitutions and 15 introductory articles by dutch specialists on the matter. There are 57 responsories and 83 antiphons. One of the responsories was written by you (in the eighties I guess) and sung each year by his schola, Caecus sedebat.

    By conincidence there is also the 8th-mode responsorium Cum turba plurima (the 1st-mode you call, by the way also 8th-mode). It was written by Van Gerven, but I'm not sure when. I think it was probably in the late eighties, or maybe early nineties. I think also that it was a copy based on Solesmes tableaux, it has number 161. It seems to be based on 11 manuscripts (not exactly matching yours). The melody does not agree with one of your manuscripts, nor with your restitution.

    Le répons Cum turba plurima
    Lien vers Cantusdatabase Tableau synoptique Propositions de restitutions: Tradition des mss en notation aquitaine (nous avons suivi Tolède 44-02):…
  • Et le répons en 8ème mode corrigé:

    9126752296?profile=original

  • Entendu.

    Merci, Jean!
     
    Jean PFLIEGER a dit :

    Merci Dominique,

    1° ℟. ligne 6, guidon fautif…

    Le répons Cum turba plurima
    Lien vers Cantusdatabase Tableau synoptique Propositions de restitutions: Tradition des mss en notation aquitaine (nous avons suivi Tolède 44-02):…
  • Très intéressant, Geert!

    Je vais regarder de près!

    Merci.

  • Dear Dominique, just to let you know,

    Yesterday in Amsterdam I presented a book with a selection of the restitutions of my gregoguru, Wim van Gerven (1929-2008). Two criteria for the selection were: handwritten and actually performed by his scholae. The book contains 197 restitutions and 15 introductory articles by dutch specialists on the matter. There are 57 responsories and 83 antiphons. One of the responsories was written by you (in the eighties I guess) and sung each year by his schola, Caecus sedebat.

    By conincidence there is also the 8th-mode responsorium Cum turba plurima (the 1st-mode you call, by the way also 8th-mode). It was written by Van Gerven, but I'm not sure when. I think it was probably in the late eighties, or maybe early nineties. I think also that it was a copy based on Solesmes tableaux, it has number 161. It seems to be based on 11 manuscripts (not exactly matching yours). The melody does not agree with one of your manuscripts, nor with your restitution.

    054-2-Cum-turba.jpg

    https://storage.ning.com/topology/rest/1.0/file/get/9126750687?profile=original
  • Merci Dominique,

    1° ℟. ligne 6, guidon fautif…

This reply was deleted.