"What an amazing database, Warwick!"

"Thank you both for another source! I think the DIAMM database owes a great deal to the work of scholars communicating through Musicologie Médiévale, particularly Dominique, and we are all grateful that you are able to share your information with us.…"

"It seems that you are seriously looking for a legal advice and you will hardly be surprised not to find it here (of course, I cannot judge Gillian's advices for Julia, who knows). I am quite sure that being anachronistic had been always the main…"

"Copyright protects the intellectual property rights of editors, web authors, photographers and other authors of works, or those to whom those rights are ceded. This is elementary and I would ask you to retract your statement about every published…"

"The score and the music it represents are 2 different things protected by different copyrights. Lot of the music contained in the manuscripts (which is the only thing that could still be under copyright until 2039) has been subject to "issue of…"

"I can think of no medieval manuscript that was ever published as defined in Section 175 of the Act. But this is pointless since since the question concerns images and now editions.
Publications, including websites and musical editions and their…"

"Olivier Berten a dit :
This means indeed that out of the 5 works from DIAMM published on IMSLP (I thought there were many more, given the fuzz about it), 2 are still under copyright.






Well... actually not... It took me some more time to find…"

"Jason Stoessel a dit :
In fact these sections of the act are not pertinent to perpetual copyright. Instead see SCHEDULE 1, section 13(1) of the same act. Most of this music was only published IN EDITION in recent years and some remains unpublished.…"

"I am very pleased that jurisdictional matters like copyright can provoke such an activity here. I read your opinions with great interest and it does not matter, whether I can agree or not, although I fear that Julia was right, when she wrote that it…"

"Olivier Berten a dit :
Jason Stoessel a dit :
Since I have already responded to the matter of public domain in my earlier responses, I suggest a review of them will answer your questions. But I'm afraid Monsieur Berten it is not appropriate to ask a…"

"Jason Stoessel a dit :
Since I have already responded to the matter of public domain in my earlier responses, I suggest a review of them will answer your questions. But I'm afraid Monsieur Berten it is not appropriate to ask a complete stranger…"

"Since I have already responded to the matter of public domain in my earlier responses, I suggest a review of them will answer your questions. But I'm afraid Monsieur Berten it is not appropriate to ask a complete stranger about his private…"

"Yves Chartier a dit :
Il n'en reste pas moins que l'attitude insolente de cet Edward Guo envers les éditeurs de musique frise l'indécence. S'il veut vraiment aider la musique contemporaine, qu'il en publie lui-même à ses propres frais dans sa propre…"

"En bref:
- J'ai le droit de faire ma propre copie d'une cantate de Bach et d'en faire une édition, puisque cette oeuvre est dans le domaine public.
- J'ai le droit de numériser et de diffuser sur la Toile l'édition de cette oeuvre dans la…"

"Thanks for these informations about Mr Guo. As these are rather easy to find, I guess they will take away the transparency worries of Mr Stoessel (mine are still there about his transparency about the legal informations he got on Public Domain…"